a game that profits off this many players should be able to accommodate all said players, aka there should be enough hosing to go around for anyone seeking (kind of like the real world, if we need more we build them.)

Don't try to come up with more systems to punish those that got lucky enough to win the rigged game that is housing. Put your energy in to blaming square for not providing the adequate servers to house its players. its not just housing its all servers, have you ever had to explain to your new player friend why they cant join your server till 4am? i know i have.