This has been an on and off issue for the last couple months. About 40% of the time when I hit the screenshot buttons on my PS3 controller (using SCPToolkit), NO screenshot is saved.
I was really bummed when I summoned Phoenix at the end of The Copied Factory while waiting for the slow pokes to roll on loot, got into first person view and took three screenshots of Phoenix. ONLY one of them saved, the other two did not.
The game made the camera sound effect all three times that I hit those buttons but ONLY one of them saved.
A couple weeks ago I was even more bummed when we were doing Suzaku Extreme and have five summoners with Phoenixes out during the phoenix phase. It was really cool to see nine phoenixes + Suzaku during battle—especially when someone made the funny comment "Needs more Phoenixes" so I took a screenshot, it made the camera sound effect but later that screenshot was NOT in the screenshots folder.
Googling 'FFXIV screenshots not working' ONLY brought up results regarding people getting a "screenshot failed" error message which I am NOT receiving. Plus all those results were from 2013.
Adding a negative operator '-failed' to the search only brought up a bug from January 2020 which was a conflict between AVG and FFXIV and/or Avast and FFXIV. I do not use either of those. I only use the built in Windows Security that comes with Windows 10. And FFXIV has been an exception to all types of scanning in Windows Security for ages now because of another issue back in November dealing with Avast or AVG and thought that it could happen with any security type.
So I added more negative operators to the Google search '-avast' '-AVG' but only got junk results.
There seems to be nothing regarding screenshots randomly not saving in recent times or without any security software other than the Windows one.
Does anybody know what the problem could be?