if reaper then Gaius

[Rymi64]

That's a pretty weak argument. So let's assume that people ARE right and it was Necromancer... well, Yoshi wouldn't want to confirm that. So the only option is to deny it, even laugh about it.

The fact they denied it so hard actually supports the fact that it's going to be Necromancer. "Thou dost protest too much".

Personally, I'm calling it to be Necromancer, with a Scythe for weapon, and will be the first melee caster.

If they didn't want to confirm it they wouldn't draw attention to it. They could easily just not say necromancer. Since we know the arte of necromancy is hard taboo in eorzea and most places i doubt we would get necromancer in name