Criticism of Shadowbringers and the hostility there in

[strawberrycake]

You mean story wise, gameplay wise is the worst by miles even if there wasnt any "perfect" expansion gameplay wise.

The story is good, but wont keep you subbed for long unlike a good gameplay

A lot of people confuse initial praise with a game keeping you subbed for more then the first few months, which FF did up until Shadowbringers imo. The simplification also did nothing and healers still aren't happy with it. I for one miss the tank gameplay loop not revolving around dps.