Claymore is rly underrated imo, sadly it didn't do well when it first aired it just went under peoples radar until later.
The male protagonist is insanely annoying and his voice actor makes it worse tho, but overall I think it's good ( no clue about Eng dub but it didn't sound great to me from what I heard ).
It also didn't get an actual ending they ran out of source material it kinda just ends.
Anime is kinda all over the place in general.
Imo I had a hard time taking AoT seriously because of how the drama is tuned up to 9999% to a point where it became comedic and I thought it tried a bit too hard to be '' deep '' ( the edge later on was a bit much for me ).
I watched Demon Slayer quite recently too and it's incredible in terms of animation but it has the same issue a lot of other show has of endless monologues and the same repeated sappy flashbacks and people pulling powers out their ass to win the day.
I still prefer it a lot more over Western animation, especially the creativity I dunno why Western animators don't take advantage of it more.
Animation that tries too much to immitate life is usually boring imo and a bit of a waste of the media it just works better when it's exaggerated.
But there's still certain tropes like the monologues and annoying side characters that makes it hard to watch sometimes.