Quote Originally Posted by Theodric View Post
I love it when I have room to just...go off and do my own thing. It helps keep subsequent playthroughs fresh, especially if there's branching options for quests/different ways to approach them. Such a model also lets the world be an actual world rather than something that just exists as window dressing.

I'd attribute how on rails FFXIV is to precisely why I've kind of come to no longer care much for the story. There's so little actual exploration outside of when a new expansion goes live. It's a shame so few MMO's manage to capture the same 'magic' that I felt when first trying WoW all those years ago and running around Teldrassil as a Night Elf. The sheer size of the game world impressed me, especially since I could explore higher level zones as a low level character if I felt brave or stupid enough to try. Modern MMO's seem intent on locking everything behind strict barriers.

As much as I dislike the combat in TESO, I do appreciate that it allows me to just...explore the world at will and go where I see fit. I think there's a healthy balance that can be struck between different styles but many games go too far in one direction rather than meeting halfway.
I think what helped WoW feel massive was even with fast travel...you are going to sit there and see how big everything is. In FFXIV you just....exist in one location and later on the next. Plus seeing every single quest marker on the map kills exploration because you know that it's just a dead zone.

The only exploring you really do is for sight seeing spots and I think quests are usually close to those anyway.