Integrate a personal Grade system, Based on uptime and stats,
Avoid all AOE rank F D C B A S S++
S is using cool down to mitigate 50% fight wide effect. S++ mitigating every fight wide Effect and avoid ever AOE
Uptime Rank F D C B A S S++
% of your uptime when you were using cooldowns.
if 3rd party website and figure out 100% usage of tools SE should be able to do it too.
Special Roll Rank F D C B A S S++
IE
TANK, Mitigate tank busters, keep hate, collecting adds,
Healer, Overheals, DPS regen or sheilds.
Range DPS (only really play BRD and DNC) Song up time, effect of ticks Dot %, dancing every 30 seconds and 1 min. % of time at 100% when you are wasting dps.
Melee DPS doing positions correctly, Cool down...
magic DPS NO CLUE I HATE MAGIC DPS THEY CAN ALL JUST DO THERE OWN THING... I've Tried to level BLM and RDM and they both suck.. But that just me and how I play. I know some great BLM DPS I Just don't like them... someone that plays them can come up with ideas.
end of a boss,
Report card
Uptime Rank B your best A
Avoidable dmg, Rank A your best A
Job Rank S your best S
Special rewards for getting S++ on fights.
It would give people an idea of direct feedback as to what they are doing wrong vs the community calling them out or using 3rd party tools.
Turn on or off feedback.
That accept there are 3rd party tools people already use to improve themselves but you shame them for using them. There is a seedy underbelly everyone who really cares uses fflogs + xivanalysis. but some like myself refuse because of the small chance of ban hammer who are at a disadvantage. My hubby sucks at the game. He can learn but just doesn't care to do better. I tell him how to play better and he improves every expansion toss out 1/2 of what he learned and because he plays different jobs than me I am not the best teacher but I get to do Savage and he doesn't because he isn't told where he is messing up. So I end up not doing Savage because he wants but he isn't good enough / care enough to improve to the point where he can do it.