I'm a big fan of warlocks and necromancers, but particularly the Ascian aesthetic. Speaking of dark transformations, one of my favourite in the game is the Ascian Prime form, and its lich-like look. Which apparently also doubles as a way to rekindle long lost romances.
Absolutely. This game doesn't really have much scope to play an 'evil' character, for example along the lines of the Sith, but given that darkness is just another cosmic force without any inherent alignment to it, and that you already pick up some dark/forbidden arts, I'd like something that delved deeper into that. Sort of like WoW's warlock. Especially as the Ascians are a bit more accessible to us now than they were before (barring Fandaniel, who is barely one), I'd like to see some room to pick up their arts. Alternatively, some non-"evil" way of incorporating necromancy. As a last resort, a time mage that uses darkness as their primary "element".Actually pointing at your signature image in vibes, like Sweet Home, or some of the other games I mentioned (Yuri from Shadow Hearts). A job that is clearly resting right on the edge of chaos. As mentioned in the post but also to people who have qualms with the idea of WoL willingly doing something that brings chaos.. is where I point out A. SE did it before, in this game and others, and B. that's fine the lore doesn't have to be entirely willing (like FFXI blue mage, and also like in this game already (lightwarden) and others). Some of the lore could be made much better if it wasn't purely willing (how you have to deal with your job's quest line for example could offer some really fun personal responses to npcs and as well discuss some of the morals of chaos and utilizing fire to fight fire). In real life I'm really hesitant about the idea of fighting fire with fire, just sounds like a great way to burn down the whole neighborhood and bring in many innocents.. but in games I absolutely love the dark fire with dark fire edge of chaos themes (so a job that had a bit of fun on that moral point, while also giving you a bit of an out in that it wasn't entirely willing, could be quite fun).
Yeah, I don't really enjoy tanks much, and I don't really care for the DRK quests outside of Fray (which is really the closest it got to what you're describing.) So DRK doesn't fill that void for me - although it's my go to tank if I ever do queue as one. BLM is the closest aesthetically, but it still has some distance to go.Some may point out Dark Knight but, I imagine this as a DD job and I've other issues like I just massively prefer playing Paladin in gameplay and features (and the holy knight as a tank is a favorite theme for that- so when playing Dark Knight I mostly just think "I should be playing Paladin right now" lol). Paladin is just my go to main for tanking. Also Dark Knight, imo, doesn't really capture that essence I was trying to point out with your avatar or other games edge of chaos characters. That broken nonchalant confident smile, confident yet two seconds away from exploding into pure chaos and or rage. Although to be fair the story for Dark Knight was fun and does have dark moments - it's definitely a job up there in terms of when I was paying closer attention to the story (not attempting to insult dark knight).
I'd have liked to see it with races too, as I believe it's one of those things WoW does really well - very distinctive racial design, including zones - but I think it's probably too much effort for SE to consider for XIV given how it's been designed. Definitely something I'd like for them to consider for any future MMOs. However, I do hope they'd at least think about it with jobs.On expectations- I might be a little "awwww" if we didn't get too much for this 5th but I wouldn't riot if it was more hints and less substance. Mostly I think then my response would rely on presentation. Naturally I don't want to be misled/lied to so I'd prefer if they can't then they don't lol. I'm not "unburnable" but I don't find SE to be just like an EA/Activision or something where if I don't "distrust them" I'm a fool (those companies can still make great games, and they do have talented people even in the bad ones - don't want to bag on the employees, but they've shown time and time again trusting them too much is a shame on you moment).
Since you mentioned customization and dungeon content, I personally hope for improvement of their exploration loops and the general sense of "existence" / role play. Like you might point out each job in WoW tends to have something that makes them cute both in and out of combat, FFXIV has the in-combat thing (sometimes, certain jobs are way more pronounced than others), but there is basically zero concept of this outside of bard in FFXIV. WoW does that sort of thing on multiple levels at multiple points of game play, it's not just jobs, or just races, or just a random quest. I really would like to see SE pick up on that thought process (although it's not really important to me on races, I'm fine with that being more same same... but jobs, or the general vibe of being in a location I feel they could improve). Why is dragoon taking more fall damage than any other job? Flip me a table right now, that is anti-role play lol. Small thing like fires in WoW often burn you but here it's like whatever, fire, ground, all the same thing. Now if SE is planning to cool FFXIV off and heat up another flagship mmo.. I guess hopefully they'll take that concept into their next game (and that can be a huge cool new selling point to the game) but if not... still wishing they did it here. That idea pervades many systems its not just that random jump example, like we've nearly no critters that peaceful run about and everything must aggro you for whatever reason. Extra things here and there that make a concept stand out as "that is what that would do.. yeah.. feels right...", like campfires do something. On a far greater aside and more FF specific concept I still miss airships too . . . obtaining an airship was a major memory for me in many FFs.
Although I don't really expect that (role play to suddenly be brought to the fore front).. just wanted to respond to your more specific desires with my own.
Take my money.