My play's not perfect, for sure, I have occasional fat fingers and that weird thing where one of the joysticks acts as a directional press during high movement/readjustment and stuff. I've tried the other methods, but I stick with R1 scrolling, because I arrange my skills such that my most used ones all go on the first cross bar, and the ones that only have specific timed intervals or specific uses like AOE, go on the second. The third is usually a mixture, with any leftover skills that don't see a ton of use, stuff like Passage of Arms or Rescue on top of basic combos. Helps to have some overlap for GCDs, because cycling back through takes time. I over presented the button amount, cause keyboard/mouse players always bringing up some misconception about controller play while trying to paint it up as disadvantageous.