I called up my ISP and they took a look at the ports. For some reason, the ports I need to play the game were closed. They had always been open. They reopened the ports and restarted my router and I restarted my PS4. I was able to get into the game. They also mentioned that my PS4 was connecting to some internet IP address they did not know. I am not anywhere near where I can possibly connect to another IP address either, so that part was a mystery to us both.