Will you do this on a tank new to the dungeon? I personally like learning where things spawn my first time in, but I also do every new thing as a healer first.
Player
That in itself is a toxic and elitist mentality. Unless they're intentionally slowing down a dungeon while knowing full well they can handle bigger pulls, I have to disagree with you.Here's the issue: A tank who single pulls is doing 2 things: 1) they make a 15-20 minute dungeon take 30-40 minutes. 2) They are demonstrating that they have been carried through content up until that point. They're getting kicked for such selfishness. As someone who has to join a dungeon as a non-tank to level the job, and as someone who makes Savage alts for non-Tank classes, I don't have the luxury of going in as a tank and doing it properly.
By using Duty Finder you know full well and are accepting the risk of being in a party with people whom you may deemed lesser skilled than you and I would be more than happy to deny such an absurd request to kick the Tank.
I'd go far as to rebuttal that you yourself have the full right to queue premade so you don't have to subject yourself to anyone who is unlucky enough to be performing less than your expectations.
Player
To to be fair, the only way single pulling would make a run take 15-20 minutes longer is if the dps wasn't up to snuff. But yeah, pulling a bunch and then AoEing them down is the most optimal way to go. New tanks (and yes, I consider anyone who's still green and has hit 80 for the very first time to be new for awhile) are probably going to struggle for a bit at first, so I do think that some patience and understanding is needed in those instances. Let's face it, not everyone is going to be on the same level. That's just how it is. I don't really see how wanting/expecting that type of pulling, since it's basically a community standard, is elitist and toxic though. It's just people wanting to get the most out of their time. Now if party member are bad mouthing the tank and harassing them then yeah, I could see that as being at the very least toxic. Being "elitist" typically doesn't mean what some think it means in an MMO context.Elitism, huh? Luckily, the VAST majority of players agree with me, as wall-to-wall pulling is the standard. Any tank who can't handle more then 1 pack isn't fit for play with other players. As I've had dozens of tanks kicked for such unbelievable incompetence, yah. People agree with my side most of the time.
The many good players should not bow to the apathy of the few bad ones. Unfortunately for you, the bad tank makes the PF. Not the other way around.
I'll be sure to let all the kicked tanks know that some average WHM thinks they should be allowed to waste everyone's time, though. You know, as a consolation.
If it's at level 71, I don't see why not. Unless they level skipped, the tank in a level 71 dungeon isn't new to tanking and most likely has experience in tanking 50,60 and 70 dungeons.
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
Cookie Policy
This website uses cookies. If you do not wish us to set cookies on your device, please do not use the website. Please read the Square Enix cookies policy for more information. Your use of the website is also subject to the terms in the Square Enix website terms of use and privacy policy and by using the website you are accepting those terms. The Square Enix terms of use, privacy policy and cookies policy can also be found through links at the bottom of the page.