DRK skill: Living Dead

[Bsrking5]

First, this belongs in the tanking thread. Second, holmgang only makes it so your HP can't go below 1.
Third, I think it should be changed so instead of instana dead it should converts all remaining MP to HP on a percentage ratio of 2:1. 100% MP gives back 50% HP back and so on.

[SomeRandomHuman]

First, this belongs in the tanking thread. Second, holmgang only makes it so your HP can't go below 1.
Third, I think it should be changed so instead of instana dead it should converts all remaining MP to HP on a percentage ratio of 2:1. 100% MP gives back 50% HP back and so on.

Yes Holmgang makes it so you can't drop below 1 hp, but if you keep the warrior from hitting 1 hp then what's the point of them having used their invuln in the first place then?

[Stepjam]

First, this belongs in the tanking thread. Second, holmgang only makes it so your HP can't go below 1.
Third, I think it should be changed so instead of instana dead it should converts all remaining MP to HP on a percentage ratio of 2:1. 100% MP gives back 50% HP back and so on.

While creatively, it isn't a bad idea, that would put DRK at a disadvantage in terms of damage. Many fights (particularly in Savage) have strats that involve actively using invulns, and with your idea, that would really hamper DRK's damage output as they'd have to "waste" MP on a non-DPS action. Even TBN is dps neutral when used properly since it essentially refunds the used MP.

If every single invuln had a damage reducing side effect, this might not be so bad, but since they don't, this change would hurt DRK more than their current invuln does. It's wonky, but at least with healers who are on top of things/a Whm with Bene, there's not too much to worry about.