Most people selling ingame are not Rmting they are doing it for gil. And I see nothing wrong with it, it is not different then people asking crafters to make something. How my guild bought our large house in the ARR days when they first launched.

Now the ones who are "if you want a clear contact me in X discord to discuss"... then you are getting into the fishy situations where rmt is more likely involved since the deal is being done outside the game where SE will not ban you for doing rmt deals.