I had a lot of trouble getting through this because of a bad internet connection constantly disconnecting me. I wish I could have done it all in one go for a more immersive experience, but it was still great.
MSQ
I really enjoyed how the dungeon was like a last hurrah for Norvrandt with a bunch of familiar faces chipping in to help. I don't want our journey here to end, I'm going to miss it.
The Amaurot solo duty was okay, but the stuff afterward with the Constellation Crystals had me absolutely fascinated. My first thought was that they were actually Zodiac Stones. They were obviously still a reference, but I wish they had been outright called that.
In some ways, Elidibus and the Exarch feel like parallels to each other, both working to the point of their physical/mental health decaying for a promise they made to someone else long ago, doing it to honor a name. I like that. Elidibus in general really shined in this patch; not as much as Emet may have, but Emet had more screentime. I liked what Elidibus did have to humanize him here. Especially the ending cutscene when he was on his knees with the Constellation Crystals (also, I screamed when I realized that was Emet helping in the trial). Also, Zodiark (and him) being empowered by hope and wishes for salvation makes perfect sense. Elidibus an embodiment of the very concept of a Warrior of Light was awesome.
The WoL's face after G'raha crystallized was heartwrenching. I wish there had been an "I love you" dialogue option to say to him. It was raining after I returned to the Crystarium. I'm sure that was a coincidental timing and not intended on Square's part, but it was very appropriate.
Everyone's farewells made me sad. I'm glad Halric is doing better, but I feel sad for Runar and the Chais saying goodbye to people they love. Delivering Ardbert's Crystal to Seto was a shock in this quest, but it got me tearing up. Man, I don't want Shadowbringers to end you guys. Although I really wish more time had been spent on Thancred and Ryne's personal relationship, they felt skipped over which sucks because their relationship was a highlight of the expansion. Honestly I wish there was a way for him to stay. At least she has Gaia, so she's not alone. I hope she becomes the leader of Norvrandt's new generation of heroes. Also, I really liked Thancred giving her his Gunblade off to the side. Easy to miss, but very sweet.
What an incredible end to an incredible journey. I adore these characters and this world. And needless to say, I'm absolutely beyond elated that G'raha is a Scion now.
As for Garlemald... I hope Fandaniel is an interesting villain, because lord knows Zenos isn't. I am absolutely not looking forward to him probably eating Zodiark and becoming the final boss of this story arc, but I feel like the writing is on the wall.