Class Trees

[reyre]

Quote

So wait, like a ninja Trick Attack? I will say this again but versions of what you want exist and have existed in the game and they have been removed because of player feedback. The lost of identity is not because A dps JUST does damage. And you may say whatever you want, but a class with your ideas would be nerfed into obvlion because it would be too good, and no most of the "nay sayers" would instead ask for either every class has a 30 min buff like that or for RDM to be nerfed.
I really dont think that you understand how balancing works. To put an example in HW NIN had the lowest melee dps but because it had TA it was almost always more desiered than MNK, you may think that this is good BUT and i need you to pay attention here, it did not push MNK dps high enough to be worth bringing said MNK instead you brough a DRG (another support dps). So by giving NIN this super positive debuff MNK was meme for most of the expac. So you see there was somenthing like that before, BRD had it in the form of their songs and because of it MCH got cucked. Your idea will alienate jobs instead of making them have synergy and as response to this players would, very loudly, demand for a nerf or their own from of buff, which is why now MNK is trapped behind three layers of RNG because of brotherhood, a pointless buff that affects MNKs core rotation, see its not dps thing is a rotation thing and it has been pretty badly recived by almost all MNK mains. SEE my point there?

Actually let me be blunt Jobs right now are desing to complement other jobs, but is simply not enough.