I'd like to kill the Scions

[Roda]

I'm not a fan of so easilly killing off staple characters, but if I could pick anyone I'd say Y'shtola has to go. They've "killed" her off once only to immediately bring her back, and then "killed" her again by giving her a disability that is barely ever utilized in how she is written an acted (animation-wise, not voice-wise) that is supposedly draining her life force despite her not showing any strain when she uses it (which she is constantly using it despite being able to turn it off and KNOWING it drains her life force), and then they "killed" her again by having her do the SAME copout she did before only with even FEWER consequences because Deus Ex Grandpa literally snapped his fingers and made it all better again. (Or they could just write her better. Psst, devs, just plagiarize the heck out of Toph Beifong, that's how you write a blind, sassy, magical juggernaut)

Alphinaud too. He doesn't have to die he just need to be written out of the story. Or at least not be on the front lines doing commandy stuff. To this day I have no idea why any of these adults would be taking orders from an impulsive, idealistic child who has REPEATED VERY LARGE FAILURES UNDER HIS BELT, and allowing him to continue to do a bunch of war things. Let him hang back and be a field medic, that would be great and make his character more interesting. Him being the (very pompus/smug/baby) face of the party just shatters my suspension of disbelief.

[Anienai]

Alphinaud too. He doesn't have to die he just need to be written out of the story. Or at least not be on the front lines doing commandy stuff. To this day I have no idea why any of these adults would be taking orders from an impulsive, idealistic child who has REPEATED VERY LARGE FAILURES UNDER HIS BELT, and allowing him to continue to do a bunch of war things. Let him hang back and be a field medic, that would be great and make his character more interesting. Him being the (very pompus/smug/baby) face of the party just shatters my suspension of disbelief.

Reminds me of Carrie Mathison from Homeland.

[Savagelf]

as i said i like scion i seem then like you see your ff party their enjoyable companys i like not see any more scions died please. see them like company of the ring for lord of rings

[PondHollow]

Urianger and Y'shtola are fun company, but I really would like to kill Ryne and Thancred because they are annoying. I want to see how Urianger and his ethical gambits would handle a trade-off like that: happy to join us in our continued crusades to save the world, but willing to tolerate our cold-blooded murder of Thancred and Ryne just because they're drags.

Our actions have occurred at such scale, surely many innocent people must have died because of us. (I'm not calling Ryne innocent; she is too irritating. But Thancred did some good before he became an emo.) Surely two more lives are an acceptable price to pay for aesthetics. Or even let us pick our own scions/companions, as in Divinity: Original Sin 2.

[Ceridwenae]

I don't want to murder them, but they can go on some very long holidays. I mean, I like them well enough, they all have something I appreciate or connect with, and I feel very guilty for letting my pixel twin kids down saying this, but I'd honestly swap the lot out and have Emet back. In my house. Permanently. It'd be fine. What's the worst that can happen?*

*don't answer that.

I mean, Nanamo would beg to differ with that. Unless you're not counting her as an example of dead.

She was only mostly dead, "there's a big difference between mostly dead and all dead. Mostly dead is slightly alive."

[Aneshda]

I don't want to murder them, but they can go on some very long holidays. I mean, I like them well enough, they all have something I appreciate or connect with, and I feel very guilty for letting my pixel twin kids down saying this, but I'd honestly swap the lot out and have Emet back. In my house. Permanently. It'd be fine. What's the worst that can happen?*

*don't answer that.

I would Murder everyone for Emet Selch, Elidibus, Arbert and Hythlodaeus. I would like to see Hythlodaeus getting his own Story, cause he seemd to me a good one who should get a chance. Even if they stay all in my Room and talk crap 24/7. I miss them so bad.

[craybest]

I just wanna dye their hair different colors, so not everyone has silver or light blonde hair.

[Roda]

I just wanna dye their hair different colors, so not everyone has silver or light blonde hair.

Louisioux had a thing, ok?

[Warghoul570]

OP must be from Lamia with that type of toxic mentality

[gumas]

we all here in this thread trying to decide which character in scion to kill off, and complain their "death" is not permanent and so on.

and yoshi maybe like "kill scion? bro we are bringing back papalymo on the next expansion"

lol