1. What I am arguing for, again, is the same thing I have said every single solitary time this subject has been brought up. If you can't remember then I'm not sure what to say. And if you want to question me on it I'll drag through threads and find my replies on the matter for proof. They exist, you should be able to remember something simple and straight forward when I've already gone after you for forgetting what I said previously. To reiterate though, and remember this time since you seem to have difficulty with that, I am simply saying Geomancers could be a healer. Nothing about what they have says they will be an offensive mage. So saying we need a Water mage is pretty pointless as a distinction again.

2. If the argument is that they don't need to be Caster DPS then it's really irrelevant to what I'm arguing. Because I would argue you can have a Healer Geomancer with Water offense just fine.

3. I'm not really the one arguing that we need a Water rep, so it's kind of a moot argument to pin on me.

4. If we're lowering the threshold of what counts then, again, I reiterate that it doesn't need to be a Caster to have Water representation. Which is entirely my point.

5. The Sai Taisui seem to be some sort of non-human entity, and I'm disinclined to really place much stock in what that means.

6. I mean, if they really wanted to just give Kyokuho a Conjurer moveset they could have done that. He does have a different healing spell. Which, to me, points at intent. There isn't really a good reason to change it from just Conjurer if they aren't going to use it as a hint at things.