Next Jobs

[MirronTulaxia]

Oh, I meant more Seraphor’s idea. Chemist broadly is fine, just again I don’t expect what people seem to keep pitching.

And yeah, Healers could be in a very different place. Like right now the whole concern is “how do you do shields and regents” basically, but they could turn that concern into something very different. That’s the issue really to me.

As for hints about terrain, I would honestly call the barriers a hint at that kind of theme. But it’s also part and parcel with the jobs identity. It’s much like doing Conjurer there isn’t any hints at holy but you can expect it to show up because that’s just an important aspect of the job.

[BasicBlake]

Oh, I meant more Seraphor’s idea. Chemist broadly is fine, just again I don’t expect what people seem to keep pitching.

And yeah, Healers could be in a very different place. Like right now the whole concern is “how do you do shields and regents” basically, but they could turn that concern into something very different. That’s the issue really to me.

As for hints about terrain, I would honestly call the barriers a hint at that kind of theme. But it’s also part and parcel with the jobs identity. It’s much like doing Conjurer there isn’t any hints at holy but you can expect it to show up because that’s just an important aspect of the job.

Also a class focusing on placed anything sounds so hard. Like your dps or healing would 100% be reliant on boss mechanics and people standing in things. This sounds not good outside a 4 man dungeons.

Unless it was some form of leylines type ability. Considering the focus on leylines for Geomancer in this game. Which I don’t know how would work from a healer standpoint, but playing things centered in your character is not a bad idea.

[MirronTulaxia]

Also a class focusing on placed anything sounds so hard. Like your dps or healing would 100% be reliant on boss mechanics and people standing in things. This sounds not good outside a 4 man dungeons.

Unless it was some form of leylines type ability. Considering the focus on leylines for Geomancer in this game. Which I don’t know how would work from a healer standpoint, but playing things centered in your character is not a bad idea.

That’s one of the things I listed. It’s a minor thing, but a way they can do it. I feel there are a lot of ways they could approach the concept broadly that would allow it to feel like terrain matters without it being too limiting. Honestly if they can’t do that it’ll just be another case where they made a job with an old name but couldn’t get even something central about it handled, really shouldn’t be making jobs with those names if they can’t.

[Archwizard]

Yeah, that'd be like introducing Scholar without Scan or Item Lore, or Dark Knight without sacrificial attacks, or Samurai without Gil Toss. Heaven forbid practicality and balance overrule being perfectly faithful to aesthetics from the classic games in our big throwback MMO, or the job ever be expanded to include more than that narrow scope.

[MirronTulaxia]

I mean, Scholar isn't consistent in terms of a theme (it's appeared something all of three times outside of XIV, and is different in each of them), Dark Knight is an example of that, and Samurai doesn't have that all the time either, so it's not something new for XIV. Cyan, literally the Samurai right after its introduction, doesn't use it. So I'm not sure quite what points you were hoping to make. Dark Knight should have sacrificial attacks, and it very easily could, the other two aren't remotely as uniform as you're treating them like. If you knew FF better you'd know that.

[Archwizard]

Dark Knight should have sacrificial attacks, and it very easily could

Literally is a tank. Fun for a DPS or healer maybe (particularly given the concerns about having too many healing tools and not enough uses for them), but that would be extremely counterproductive to the one role based on letting the boss beat on it.

As for SCH and SAM, the point I was trying to make is that it wouldn't be the first time the devs expanded on a job to maintain a certain theme but gain new (from the series' standpoint at least) abilities. Geomancer obviously can't stick to the classic "Terrain" command and nobody is saying it should, but there's a plethora of ways to keep within the Geomancer's core Feng Shui themes, some of which are more practical than others (such as healing primarily through stationary fields). Particularly since Geomancy has had quite a bit of expansion within the lore thanks to Stormblood.

[MirronTulaxia]

Literally is a tank. Fun for a DPS or healer maybe (particularly given the concerns about having too many healing tools and not enough uses for them), but that would be extremely counterproductive to the one role based on letting the boss beat on it.

As for SCH and SAM, the point I was trying to make is that it wouldn't be the first time the devs expanded on a job to maintain a certain theme but gain new (from the series' standpoint at least) abilities. Geomancer obviously can't stick to the classic "Terrain" command and nobody is saying it should, but there's a plethora of ways to keep within the Geomancer's core Feng Shui themes, some of which are more practical than others (such as healing primarily through stationary fields). Particularly since Geomancy has had quite a bit of expansion within the lore thanks to Stormblood.

My idea for Dark Knight would be HP Bubbles, which lets you do "sacrifices" without it being too much.

And I would say there is a big difference between "we just created these jobs and we have it do something different"/"we're bringing back this really old job no one has used in a decade and doing something different with it" and "here's a job we've had in the series for the last 30 years, with multiple incarnations, and all of them manage to have this feature". Though I'm not even sure that you understand what I mean by Terrain given you're throwing out stationary healing fields when that was... literally one of my suggestions. I'm not suggesting that it has abilities based on where it's at in terms of like, landscape or the like, I don't think that's reasonable at all. But bounded fields or the like are certainly options, again something like leylines could work too, so on and so forth.

[Archwizard]

Though I'm not even sure that you understand what I mean by Terrain given you're throwing out stationary healing fields when that was... literally one of my suggestions. I'm not suggesting that it has abilities based on where it's at in terms of like, landscape or the like, I don't think that's reasonable at all. But bounded fields or the like are certainly options, again something like leylines could work too, so on and so forth.

No, I was putting stationary healing fields in the "others" category in my original post, as opposed to the "some more practical than" category.
As in, like Blake said before, stationary fields would be a terribly impractical way to go about facilitating the core of its hypothetical healing considering the amount of mobility required of players in most raid content.

[gumas]

My idea for Dark Knight would be HP Bubbles, which lets you do "sacrifices" without it being too much.

dark knight should have hp bubble shield by sacrificing some of the ENTIRE party HP, so he take like 20% of each member in the party which result him with 60% HP bubble.

i think thats how a dark knight should be, he is a knight who use dark arts, he take whatever it mean to "finish the job" lol

[MirronTulaxia]

No, I was putting stationary healing fields in the "others" category in my original post, as opposed to the "some more practical than" category.
As in, like Blake said before, stationary fields would be a terribly impractical way to go about facilitating the core of its hypothetical healing considering the amount of mobility required of players in most raid content.

Ah. I think it depends on how they approach it still. Again if they can’t do it right there isn’t much point in including it either. I’m not sure why people are so opposed to something not a Geomancer having a different name. Call it a Terramanter or some such. It’s what 1.0 did after all, to some it’s what Astrologian is to Time Mage. It’s just a simpler solution all around. If you don’t care about the jobs history then there isn’t any reason to care about the name used. *shrugs* But Yoshida is welcome to do whatever, not like I can control him. It simply makes no sense to me.

dark knight should have hp bubble shield by sacrificing some of the ENTIRE party HP, so he take like 20% of each member in the party which result him with 60% HP bubble.

i think thats how a dark knight should be, he is a knight who use dark arts, he take whatever it mean to "finish the job" lol

My thought was more along the lines of you have special “extra HP”, represented as HP bubbles. They can only be filled by Dark Knight moves and expended using certain commands. I’m still stuck on if they should be the top HP (which would make it harder to fill but more relevant) or bottom HP (easier to fill and kind of an emergency supply, but it’ll get used for tanking purposes less often). I suppose you could get a mechanic that switches its position perhaps? That might be best. It’s bottom most in charging mode, top most when you’re actively using it. I don’t want it to be normal HP as that would make healers jobs more difficult, but this way it’s still HP and can help with tanking.