Would you enjoy an arc where the WoL/WoD goes rogue (5.0 spoiler within)

[Kallera]

My example was never meant to imply going rogue. I dont want us to go rogue (and the OPs question was if we would enjoy that). Honestly I want a good written story that makes sense (including how the characters act). I dont need shock and tragedy for the sake of it. Thus I would not enjoy if suddenly we would just turn our back on everyone..I see no good reason in this existing story to do that.

Well, I would like a story where we “go rogue”. And I think Ilsabard and the Garlean country would be a great place to explore how we look from a less reputable perspective, we don’t need stereotypical Garlean racism to give a people reason to see the WoL, in not the same light as Eorzeans do.

Perhaps “going rogue” would be the way that we attempt to circumvent this, only for the reveal to complicate matters further as the WoL is rejected.

Or we end up “going rogue” in response to the rejection, throwing the reputation as “Eorzea’s champion” to the wind to get across the idea that, “there are bigger things at stake”, and, even if they are facing rejection, is in their choice to do the right thing.

So I guess agree to disagree, because I see worth in that sort of story. Unlike in Ishgard, where we were treated like a nobody until we were not, here it would be a reputation we have already garnered before our arrival(in my previous example, the people we killed, bad things people did inspired by us, etc.) that proves our hurdle.