Quote Originally Posted by Shougun
Judgment would actually be a spell you charged and didn't require requisecat, unlike Confiteor. . I believe that makes them different enough, they're both big cool spells but judgement would be on a much bigger looser loop (you could hardcast clemency or not).
Being different enough does not necessarily make an ability a good inclusion. As you currently have it described Judgment's usage would have it either being used every minute after the Requisecat burst (which now replaces a Holy Spirit with a Clemency and then follows up Confiteor with Judgement) or once you get max stacks which could take multiple minutes by your description.

A far simpler method of making Clemency more usable would be to have is grant a simple buff on something like a 30s timer that iincreases the potency of the next Confiteor by the potency of a Holy Spirit (currently 350).

Quote Originally Posted by Mithia View Post
If we are talking about pure damage, then I'd rather see the job gauge provide something of use other then defensive tools. Sure, sheltron and intervention are nice, but I'd rather see different uses than just those 2. Yes, I know cover is there as well.
Bad idea. Tying damage to a defensive resource will just make it so that the defense usage because non-omptimal and therefore useless according to ffxiv's dps centric meta.