Is TBN a bad skill?

[Shougun]

Not a frequent user of DRK but having leveled it up all the way and played it a little bit I think it's a pretty neat skill and I only wished it was easier to break when solo lol (not asking for a smaller shield just the threshold for the bonus perhaps being a % of the shield).

Perhaps they could add two tiers, one tier being the generic fairly long lasting shield we've already (with an easier to reach threshold for the free spell), and the other being a much shorter duration shield that gives you a bonus of some sort if you crack it (but you have to time it even better, or are being pummeled from all sides lol)- bonus may simply be igniting nearby enemies in dark flames for a second dealing extra potency or something. Which could be nice as it would be a competitive dps choice assuming you can time that thinner slice.

Though I don't main DRK, just sharing experience while leveling it up- basically done zero hard content with it and I imagine it's quite easy to crack as MT on any content that you're not massively over scaling.

[Stepjam]

TBN isn't combining dps and mitigation. If it breaks, you are dps neutral, so there's no incentive to actively use it.

There was an argument that it was a dps gain back in SB when it gave you blood gauge upon breaking, but I believe it was a gcd then so it was still neutral

[Hierro]

TBN isn't combining dps and mitigation. If it breaks, you are dps neutral, so there's no incentive to actively use it.

There was an argument that it was a dps gain back in SB when it gave you blood gauge upon breaking, but I believe it was a gcd then so it was still neutral

How about doing your job? that incentive enough for ya?

[Stepjam]

How about doing your job? that incentive enough for ya?

...I never said I had a problem with it

Actively as in like using it actively just to break it, not just using it to block damage.

[Quor]

TBN isn't combining dps and mitigation. If it breaks, you are dps neutral, so there's no incentive to actively use it.

There was an argument that it was a dps gain back in SB when it gave you blood gauge upon breaking, but I believe it was a gcd then so it was still neutral

It's not a *personal* dps gain, but it is an overall dps gain as less damage that needs to be healed equals more healer GCD's spent not healing. If TBN let's your WHM get one extra Holy off on 6 targets that's 840 potency gained over what they would have had to do. Worst case scenario with an AST on single target you gain 250 potency. If you can save three healer GCD's per minute you're getting 750-900 potency more than you would every 60s. Over the course of a 10 minute fight you're looking at over 7k potency just in healer GCD's if you do it correctly. That's basically a free melee LB1.

[Tracewood]

TBN makes long pulls a lot less scary, as long as you have the MP to keep it going. Love taking on heavy hitting moves and popping that right before it goes off.

[AC9Breaker]

I think its one of the best tank skills in game.

[NarutobandHD]

I would say it's closer to bad in the sense of if the boss is too weak to pop it in the opener, like in E6s, your opener gets completely messed up and it's simply out of your hands. Now if it worked like SAM's Third Eye where the effect pops on any hit, then it would be better but still not great cause then you'd end up using a Dark Arts charge instead of Mp in the opener which would lead to overcapping. So then Dark Arts would also need to be changed to be used on something else entirely. It's kind of a mess.

[ItMe]

I would say it's closer to bad in the sense of if the boss is too weak to pop it in the opener,

The opener is made to work without it.
After all, you won't always be MT.

[Absurdity]

I would say it's closer to bad in the sense of if the boss is too weak to pop it in the opener, like in E6s,

You could always take off your gear, put TBN on yourself or your co-tank (who would have to be naked in that case) and put it back on right before the pull. TNB scales with the HP your target has at the time of casting it so no gear = less HP = lower shield.