Geomancer

[Claire_Pendragon]

I don't really see how that's relevant. Quick 2-hand sword, punch and kick, sword and board. They're not in the slightest similar in presentation.

As far as we know with GEO, it's CNJ+ in presentation: Earth, wind, water. Something we already have, or at least we had.

He's "somewhat" correct, if you compare staff vs bells, in the same way you compared 2hand sword vs 1 hand sword. (DRK would be the better example, as its 2hand sword vs 2hand sword, knight vs eastern knight. Granted both are only SAM/DRK in name)
But I also agree, the general theme feels too similar, and I honestly feel that way about all 3 healers. (and to a degree, all 4 tanks)

It’s relevant because you said the concept was lame.

Its not that GEO is lame in a vacuum. It's only when you look at how we currently have something so similar, and theres tons of other themes we still lack. (And we will never get them. So realistically, we should only be looking at reskinned WHMs anyways, since thats all we'll ever be allowed to have in MMOs)