Requesting Makai Achievements Account Wide

[Gula]

So, Makai event is over. I got the achievements across multiple alts, got my mounts and titles. However, I think it would be nice to have said achievements account wide the way Chocobo Feathers are. In the event someone creates an alt, they can purchase their earned items with gil from the Calamity Salvager.

[awesomega]

ultimately idc if they randomly implement your suggestion, but they should make mogstation stuff account wide first

[Gula]

That is not something they can just do. The mogstation decisions are separate marketing, not core gameplay and QoL.

[Commander_Justitia]

I dont get why people wanna play alts in this game of all games, it makes the least sense.

Anyway, they could only implement it if they go the same way like WoW for example, making all achievements accountwide - so they share it. The same way all mounts could be account wide.

But if you think more about the suggestion, it would mean one character shares all the past seasonal event items and mounts to all other account characters. It would mean you can go on another datacenter make a character and share items that are usually bought now with mogstation money. It would be a loss of profit to them.

Creating it only for Garo achievements would look akward and half baked and community would demand a general solution for this kinda problem. So they do nothing and don't lose profit, seems like the efficient way.

[Gula]

I dont get why people wanna play alts in this game of all games, it makes the least sense.

Yoshi-P has alts on all worlds, some people have friends in the community world wide, and it is especially common for decorators and rolelayers. Because you personally do not do it does not mean it does not make sense.

[Esmoire]

In my case I have people I like to PvP with on Aether. That makes me wonder how things will be like when we have cross-DC play on the region.

As for the thread, yeah, I endorse making this and more account-wide.

[Commander_Justitia]

Yoshi-P has alts on all worlds, some people have friends in the community world wide, and it is especially common for decorators and rolelayers. Because you personally do not do it does not mean it does not make sense.

Dude Yoshi P has alts on all worlds cause there was no world transfer and he made appearances to say hello for community events, its not like he vigorously enjoys playing on 30 alts. Yes it is used for roleplay, idk why for decorators, but whatever. For the big majority it doesnt make any sense, its not like you can only level one class with on character like in so many other games.

My point still stands, if you make garo items account wide with achievements sharing to alts then people gonna wonder why only Garo achievements are shared and nothing else. And if you let them share all account rewards to their alts, you will make less money from RP people buying their alts more mogstation glam. And that sucks economically. So why would they do it?
It is the same reason you only are allowed 2 retainer, while you need way more if you dont want to throw away everything all the time if you are crafting or even gathering. Its free money to sell another 8 retainer, why fix the inventory mess.

Garo was running for years, you missed it on your alt, it was advertised multiple times as being time limited. And had big news towards the end that it is ending. Not like when they shut down diadem in 3 days and made content unaccessible forever.

[Gula]

Dude Yoshi P has alts on all worlds cause there was no world transfer and he made appearances to say hello for community events, its not like he vigorously enjoys playing on 30 alts. Yes it is used for roleplay, idk why for decorators, but whatever. For the big majority it doesnt make any sense, its not like you can only level one class with on character like in so many other games.

My point still stands, if you make garo items account wide with achievements sharing to alts then people gonna wonder why only Garo achievements are shared and nothing else. And if you let them share all account rewards to their alts, you will make less money from RP people buying their alts more mogstation glam. And that sucks economically. So why would they do it?
It is the same reason you only are allowed 2 retainer, while you need way more if you dont want to throw away everything all the time if you are crafting or even gathering. Its free money to sell another 8 retainer, why fix the inventory mess.

Garo was running for years, you missed it on your alt, it was advertised multiple times as being time limited. And had big news towards the end that it is ending. Not like when they shut down diadem in 3 days and made content unaccessible forever.

1. You said, and I quoted "I dont get why people wanna play alts in this game of all games, it makes the least sense." Speaking objectively, I am answering you. Yoshi P has alts, and you said it did not make sense. But now, you are justifying it. I guess it makes sense then.
2. An alt can be made at any time. If I create one on Aether tomorrow, I am not at fault for being unable to predict the future. I did not miss anything at the time of the event and either I was not clear enough (and if so oops my bad) or you have misread my first post.

[Commander_Justitia]

1. But now, you are justifying it. I guess it makes sense then.
2. I am not at fault for being unable to predict the future. I did not miss anything at the time of the event

1. No it still doesn't make much sense.
2. You didn't need to predict the future, it was already known what happens to your alts. It is your fault. It is not SE fault for not predicting your future self playing an alt that cares about Garo gear. Don't be so entitled. Garo event wasn't any different than other seasonal stuff besides the duration... Do I get the christmas, easter, summer, halloween, dragonquest and moogle items on my other alts aswell? No, I don't. Only limiting it to Garo, doesn't make sense, and I said that already 2 times before. You need to change your inital suggestion or you won't get much support.

It is like people wanting rating decay in PvP but don't say how to implement it properly. And then notice it can't be implemented properly or fairly.