i feel that f2p will bring in more players but i think it would be the wrong kind of players. f2p is aimed towards a younger audience who doesn't have or aren't old enough to have debit/credit cards so they can play all they want without having to spend any money. this creates a disparity with hardcore older players who can shell out a lot of money trying to weed out the younger players who are just playing to have fun and pass the time.

i do prefer a monthly fee but i would also welcome some sort of small microtransaction. nothing that improves your character but stuff like suits/dresses, show weapons/armor, maybe different style mounts for ur chocobo. stuff thats doesn't have any stat benefits and mainly for appearance.