I enjoy PUG a lot. My issues are that Simian Thrash is reliant on evasion as others have pointed out. It's a good skill but it's not so good that we should have to evade in order to use it. With it being a multi-hit WS, there can be quite a lot of misses, making Victimize II a better option for a lot of situations.

The effects of our skills are also very lackluster as with most classes.

I do have to praise SE on giving us the ability to tank pretty well on most fights. I honestly didn't expect PUG to be very good at it when I started but it really is a pretty good tanking class and is fantastic for off-tanking.