I went with one of each and went with Rodrigault a second time.

I think people are taking Rodrigault's comments out of context.

I think he more so saw Sylphie as a better matchmaker than Astrid? while Astrid is more childish and lovey dovy (and gave the wrong advice...oh dear) Sylphie is more like a little sister or niece who just wants to help her big brother or uncle find someone?