Valentines day event fail

[SturmChurro]

The game never accepts that it's inappropriate for Ywain to be treated that way and there's a track record of the game taking a firm stance against men being emotionally or physical abusive towards female characters, to the point where there is always punishment inflicted upon the offending parties in such cases.

It may or may not lead to Ywain actually getting into a relationship with Marcette, though the game certainly pushes it as the intention and something Astrid and Lisette take pride in. Something tells me Lisette would never allow Astrid to be treated in such a manner, but even if you pick the least disapproving option of Ywain's circumstances in dialogue it'd just hand-waved away.

It does, that's why they chose her probably (an obnoxious past quest giver). My character has always been a female and from what I vaguely remember of that quest when I did it, she treated my character the exact same way as what I read here (I haven't logged into the game today yet). It's supposed to be funny because Astrid and Lisette are dumb, and have no idea how to actually make a match even though they claim they are match makers or whatever. Actually, that would be the joke of the whole event, none of them know what they are doing despite claiming they are "match makers" or whatever. I think people are really stretching here.

[Ammokkx]

He was t h i r s t y for the WoL

I looked it up and... my god...

...that's absolutely hilarious. I'm sad they changed that, the man's bold and knows what he wants.

[Teeko]

It irrationally frustrates me that other voters lack of caring (which has been admitted several times in this very thread) affects my gameplay and quest outcome.

Make a stupid popularity contest for the costumes and decorations if you must but don't let it decide which cutscenes I see in the game. I play this game for story, immersion, and atmosphere- that is what is important to me and that shouldn't be affected by others.

I literally had to seek out an outside source website to determine the outcome of the event from the other choices and that doesn't sit very well with me.

Please reconsider this for events in the future.

[SingleMaltFan]

I'm glad the quest text for Astrid's result is available:

https://ffxiv.gamerescape.com/wiki/Astrid%27s_Acumen

Now I don't have to endure the quest itself.

This is not cool, SE. Playing abuse for laughs and even hinting that men LIKE to be abused is over the line. Reverse the genders and this would never have seen the light of day.

If you think I'm taking this too seriously because it's "just a game," then fine. You're entitled to your opinion. For me, I refuse to even complete the quest.

[Infindox]

It irrationally frustrates me that other voters lack of caring (which has been admitted several times in this very thread) affects my gameplay and quest outcome.

Make a stupid popularity contest for the costumes and decorations if you must but don't let it decide which cutscenes I see in the game. I play this game for story, immersion, and atmosphere- that is what is important to me and that shouldn't be affected by others.

I literally had to seek out an outside source website to determine the outcome of the event from the other choices and that doesn't sit very well with me.

Please reconsider this for events in the future.

Yeah that's definitely one of my complaints. Sure, some of the events are dumb (I barely remember Heavensturn) but I love the bit of lore we get in each, and some of the funny interactions.

[dinnertime]

Their ideas and outcomes were all terrible.
Anyway, I just think it's a silly little event so I wouldn't take it too seriously.

[AngelCheese77]

If this is true, it is very disappointing to hear. I would also like to see the voting results for each NPC on the servers.

[NessaWyvern]

I chose Rodrigault and I am happy knowing it was ultimately the best choice for a real chance at love. He would have lead Ywain to someone who could have legitimately helped him. Instead Ywain becomes a victim. Great Job SE. You're perpetuating stereotypes and advocating male relationship abuse for a laugh..

Astrid's idea was TERRIBLE. How is this acceptable? How did this pass QA? (emphasis mine)

Oh gods, that is truly terrible.
I come from a country that has a serious problem with domestic abuse, (and has been a serious problem in my extended family) and I actually feel physically sick reading it. I know it's just a game, but poor Ywain.

[Theodric]

It's a shame we didn't have the option to have our own character flirt with Ywain. He's very much my type of guy to begin with. Even if he wasn't interested, it'd at least be a big confidence boost for the Warrior of Light to compliment him.

[Gula]

It's a shame we didn't have the option to have our own character flirt with Ywain. He's very much my type of guy to begin with. Even if he wasn't interested, it'd at least be a big confidence boost for the Warrior of Light to compliment him.

Considering I pick the sauciest response every single time I can as the WoL, yes. I was even thinking it when I did the initial quests. Imagine, having the Warrior of Light as someone asking you out. Naturally, for neutrality, he could refuse and just like Magnai would lead nowhere. But it would have been an option I'd have picked without a second thought.