Quote Originally Posted by TwiibieTwuu View Post
Reading the quest logs on the wiki they all kinda are only partially successful.
Oh hey, they did actually write up alternate scenarios.

So apparently, if Bert won then Ywain would've been forcibly made a part of the Carpenter's Guild by Beatin while Rodrigault would've sent Ywain to the Conjurer's Guild after which point Sylphie would've grabbed him for dating advice.