Can we get choices that really matter and have a effect?

[LolitaBansheeMeru]

This is, unironically, the funniest thing you've ever posted.

how is that funny ...

Yes A person could make fanfaction but honestly no one even really looks at fan fiction storys

As for what I want is for them stop given us a character we can relate to then killing them off because they are"bad"I fell in love with both Emet, and zenos from the start

its like what rwby did to Adam taurs when he had every right to want humanity destoryed and you felt for him and agreed

[KalinOrthos]

how is that funny ...

Yes A person could make fanfaction but honestly no one even really looks at fan fiction storys

As for what I want is for them stop given us a character we can relate to then killing them off because they are"bad"I fell in love with both Emet, and zenos from the start

its like what rwby did to Adam taurs when he had every right to want humanity destoryed and you felt for him and agreed

Oh. Oh no. Oh sweety, did you genuinely relate to Emet-Selch and Zenos? And not just sympathize with them because they had an understandable motive to their rampant murder? Because most sane people just look at them and say "Cool motive; still murder." Because the atrocities they both commit are...well, atrocities. Emet has instituted mass genocide, not only on the shards but also on the Source. Zenos has not only wantonly killed civilians and his own subordinates, but has overseen the brutal suppressive regime on Doma. They are undoubtedly evil and in direct opposition to us, and you want to join them because "waaah i just want to have my old world back" and "waaah i had a bad childhood"? Are you for real?

[LolitaBansheeMeru]

Oh. Oh no. Oh sweety, did you genuinely relate to Emet-Selch and Zenos? And not just sympathize with them because they had an understandable motive to their rampant murder? Because most sane people just look at them and say "Cool motive; still murder." Because the atrocities they both commit are...well, atrocities. Emet has instituted mass genocide, not only on the shards but also on the Source. Zenos has not only wantonly killed civilians and his own subordinates, but has overseen the brutal suppressive regime on Doma. They are undoubtedly evil and in direct opposition to us, and you want to join them because "waaah i just want to have my old world back" and "waaah i had a bad childhood"? Are you for real?

Well I'm going to ignore that bottom part because thats personal to that I will say sometimes what Emet ,niddhog or even in rwby Adam did is the true justice and greatest good thats all I'll say to it to. Also your correct most people would say that because most people haven't experienced anything real to make them realize that sometimes great evil is the greatest good. That and they let society brain wash them to the point they cant think for themself.

[TheMightyMollusk]

I can't help but notice that the people who ask for more player choice in the story are usually the ones who want to side with the villains, no matter how obviously violent, deranged, insane, and/or genocidal they are. It's kind of concerning.

[LolitaBansheeMeru]

I can't help but notice that the people who ask for more player choice in the story are usually the ones who want to side with the villains, no matter how obviously violent, deranged, insane, and/or genocidal they are. It's kind of concerning.

not really if you were in Emets shoes you would do the exact same thing he was doing ... everyone would and well honestly if you had any of those characters experience you would do the same thing .. nothing concerning about it just the way things work

[Edax]

not really if you were in Emets shoes you would do the exact same thing he was doing ... everyone would and well honestly if you had any of those characters experience you would do the same thing .. nothing concerning about it just the way things work

I would never choose genocide. If my people had been destroyed, I would have mourned their loss, erected a memorial and moved on.

[LolitaBansheeMeru]

I would never choose genocide. If my people had been destroyed, I would have mourned their loss, erected a memorial and moved on.

really you would pretend like nothing happan while the people who forgot everything praises the one that destroyed your people like she is the hero doing nothing to change anything that is a type of betrayerl you know.

[Valkyrie_Lenneth]

really you would pretend like nothing happan while the people who forgot everything praises the one that destroyed your people like she is the hero doing nothing to change anything that is a type of betrayerl you know.

Would you betray the memories of those who died by killing millions sacrificing them to a "God" to maybe bring back some facet of them, which may or may not actually succeed and may only make things worse?

[Edax]

I would never choose genocide. If my people had been destroyed, I would have mourned their loss, erected a memorial and moved on.

really you would pretend like nothing happan while the people who forgot everything praises the one that destroyed your people like she is the hero doing nothing to change anything that is a type of betrayerl you know.

No, I would mourn the dead and erect a memorial. That's the opposite of "pretend like nothing happan". Attempting to raise the dead is not a heroic action.

[AnimaAnimus]

I would never choose genocide. If my people had been destroyed, I would have mourned their loss, erected a memorial and moved on.

But if the souls of your people were shattered and you were able to reconstruct them, is it really genocide? Hydaelyn was more the perpetrator of genocide than the ascians in this situation. And wouldn't undoing that genocide be the actual good thing to do? Isn't that what we should be rooting for?

I look at the souls of the ascians as vases that zodiarc was in charge of keeping safe after an earthquake nearly knocked them over. Hydaelyn, however, pushed him out of the way and smashed all the vases with a hammer, missing only a few, then locked zodiarc outside. She then rearranged the shards to serve her own purpose,, but how is breaking back into the room, pushing her out of the way and reconstructing those pieces back into a whole vase again, be akin to or even worse than, their initial destruction?

The ascians do not want to destroy the world, they simply want to put the pieces of the world back together after a complete psychopath barged in an smashed it.