Seems like they're trying to hand wave it as "PC is special".The "starshower" in 1.0 is canonically debris from Dalamud falling. Just about everyone in Eorzea saw it and the vast majority of them did not end up with the Echo afterwards. It should be noted that everyone that did have an awakened Echo did see the Starshower.
In 2.0, it's very odd. In the opening scene of 2.0, we hear Hydaelyn and swipe at Lahabrea in the Aetherial Sea. Which is long before we even see a starshower. The starshower we do see isn't even real. It happens after we pick up our first crystal of light and happens in the Aetherial Sea where our Crystals of Light are. Which happens after we hear Hydaelyn for the first time.
This is less of a problem for 1.0 legacy characters, who would have already had the Echo at this point anyway. It's a bigger issue for everyone else since the start of 2.0 is when they would have gotten the Echo most likely.
Well, something to consider:I don't understand the Echo now. I need to go back and re-watch the cutscene of Elidibus explaining it. But it seems, just based on what I heard, that we aren't all that important after all. That anyone can be the WoL if they hear Hydaelyn's voice during a starshower. And that the Echo itself is a memory of the Final Days etched onto the souls of all the mortal races. So, from what I understand, Hydaelyn's message, "Hear...Feel...Think" is playing in a loop constantly and that anyone who hears it is taken by Hydaelyn to be her champion and receive her blessing. In this regard, there is absolutely NOTHING special about the WoL. We are, for all intents and purposes, glamorized (no pun intended) grunts. Made to feel special. When in fact, we are not.
The Echo isn't what makes the WoL special. Even before this, there are many people with the Echo, and the WoL is just one of them. Far less people have the Blessing of Light - but even that isn't what makes the WoL special. The WoL makes the WoL special. That was hammered into us by the storyline where Midgardsormr took away our Blessing. The story wanted to make it clear that we are our own person. Our triumphs are our own. The Blessing is a shield that defends us at times, and the Echo can be a useful information-gathering tool - but that's all it and the Blessing are. Tools. Hydaelyn happens to be fond of us, and we're likely the greatest ally she has, but we're special because we're a phenomenally powerful and talented individual, with a penchant for doing great deeds.
I do wonder, though:
Did EVERYONE in the crowd who saw the starshower gain the Echo? Did everyone even see it? I got the feeling that while many have the potential for the Echo, not everyone has that potential. If Elidibert's words are true, Hydaelyn occasionally shows the starshower to select individuals to awaken the Echo within them. Elidibert, on the other hand, awakened the Echo in a lot of people indiscriminately...
Last edited by LineageRazor; 02-21-2020 at 05:56 AM.
When is it said the starshower in 1.0 is Dalamud? I played 1.0 from the very beginning. You see the starshower in the first 10 seconds of the game and then you’re immediately echo’d back 10 years into the past.The "starshower" in 1.0 is canonically debris from Dalamud falling. Just about everyone in Eorzea saw it and the vast majority of them did not end up with the Echo afterwards. It should be noted that everyone that did have an awakened Echo did see the Starshower.
In 2.0, it's very odd. In the opening scene of 2.0, we hear Hydaelyn and swipe at Lahabrea in the Aetherial Sea. Which is long before we even see a starshower. The starshower we do see isn't even real. It happens after we pick up our first crystal of light and happens in the Aetherial Sea where our Crystals of Light are. Which happens after we hear Hydaelyn for the first time.
This is less of a problem for 1.0 legacy characters, who would have already had the Echo at this point anyway. It's a bigger issue for everyone else since the start of 2.0 is when they would have gotten the Echo most likely.
The strength of the Echo:
As Elidibus stated the strength of the Echo varies based on any given individual's sundered state. Even then, they boast but a fraction of the power that the Ancients once had at their disposal. So anybody on the First who happens to be granted the Echo is still going to be much weaker than someone on the Source who also has the Echo. With the Warrior of Light/Darkness now standing above even that due to being just a bit more rejoined than everybody else on the Source. It also explains why Lahabrea and Emet-Selch could not be defeated through conventional means.
Agreed, there are differences in its intensity...
... presumably based on how complete the soul is. I'm also keen to find out if it was everyone who received this newly awakened "gift", as it has implications as to whether everyone could potentially have it awakened. The wording Urianger used, "full many in the crowd", would suggest it's not all, but leaves none the wiser as to the why. Could have something to do with how weakened the cycle of rebirth has left some souls.
When the game's story becomes self-aware:
*cough*
MSQ:
team #neitherprimal
Tho that does solve the mystery that was always nagging at me when I went back and forth on the matter before. If the WoL was the sacrifice it would mean it's BEFORE a state of sundering and WoL wouldn't exactly exist. At least that's how it kinda stood to me. It...didn't mesh right.
There are still a few pieces to fit in of course one of which was Hydaelyn's call and saying Zodiark coveted more power.
This actually seems to maybe support the idea that while Hydaelyn's original intent is to be the failsafe. I feel like the primals are a form of "wish corruption". You kinda get what you think you want but I don't think the Ancients were above creating faulty "Gods" even their magic is faulty. So I always personally believed Hydaelyn wasn't above it - I think she was a well intended solution but the road to hell is paved with good intentions.
By that I mean Venat's dialog about Elidibus. These two don't really seem to have animosity towards each other, but different philosophy. So when you hear Hydaelyn talk about Zodiark coveting power. The bias is in there, though she avoids talking in a negative manner just like Venat.
The identity of the other White robed figure. I think okay, from the VA and figure it's "Asahi" but at the same time it's kinda like WHY. It's either another "Body snatch" or "another back from the dead" Hell maybe they're looking to explain why our WoL just kinda sat there while he shot away at Yotsuyu
There's still of course many more mysteries from the trailer and - one rather big unanswered question of *how* those "3" escaped sundering.
Last edited by QT_Melon; 02-21-2020 at 07:59 AM.
If the echo is just a fraction of the hidden power awakened in everyone from the presundered era by viewing the vision of the final day, how is it that the ancient ascians were tempered by zodiark? I thought echo by it's nature makes you immune to tempering.
/10 char. . .
The starshower awakening is only part of it. Hearing Hydaelyn is the part that protects you from tempering. Hydaelyn didn’t exist yet so they had nothing to protect them from Zodiark.
Anyone else notice how the pilot for the Ruby Weapon was female and the "battle data" was from "Nael", so that when the over soul emerged it looked female. It's just another subtle reference to the Nael we know being Eula. But I wonder who the other Oversoul Legatus battle data could be. I can see/picture Regula for one, possibly Sapphire since it was mentioned, but I think we need another dead guy to round out the trio.
I like helping people with their Job ideas, it's fun to help them visuallize and create the job they'd like to play most. Plus I make my own too, I'll post them eventually.
HUH? *headscratch*
We don't know that, as Zodiark may have given it after the fact. We don't know if it was Hydaelyn or Zodiark's involvement - it could have been the WoL for all we know
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
Cookie Policy
This website uses cookies. If you do not wish us to set cookies on your device, please do not use the website. Please read the Square Enix cookies policy for more information. Your use of the website is also subject to the terms in the Square Enix website terms of use and privacy policy and by using the website you are accepting those terms. The Square Enix terms of use, privacy policy and cookies policy can also be found through links at the bottom of the page.