Mentors...please!

[SoranRigel]

You were talking about silence tho.
We can argue wether or not that mentor was a dumb dumb for pulling too much, but being not very smart and being toxic are two very different things.

If you want to make foolishness report-able, ok, well, idk, but you just assumed this mentor was toxic and had selfish intentions, but you don't know for sure. Still disagree to this being toxic tho.
Becoming a mentor has nothing to do with your skill tho. You don't need to be a good player to become a mentor and while I think this is a problem, idk how this problem could be solved any other way than making savage clears a requirement. But then again rAiDeRs ArE tOxIc AnD eLiTiSt.

Did you really see just that? In this case, I understand why in this discussion it is customary to ignore the proof and turn uncomfortable examples inside out.

This dishonest discussion technique is called “pushing back the gate": no matter what evidence you are presented with, your bar of "convincing evidence" will arbitrarily shift. It has already been repeatedly.

Someone in this thread asked me to provide evidence that the recommendation system needs to be reformed. I quoted the same player in another topic, where she admits that she gives recommendations for beautiful glamor, completely not paying attention to how much this person knows the content.
For this proof, I was called a "stalker", although the discussion was just next door.

[AmeliaVerves]

Did you really see just that?

The thing is, everything that came after was pure assumption. He doesn't know anything of why the mentor acted the way he did. Maybe he just didn't know better.
As I said before: you do not need to be anywhere near decent in skill to become a mentor and just because the person kept going without talking doesn't mean it was a bad intention. In that very example I do not see anything toxic going on.
Yes, it was heckin stupid to keep pulling big but idk what to tell you. I main healers ever since HW, but I can't heal stupid and neither can SE. Kick the tank or leave the dungeon and move on, ppl are dumb sometimes and no system in the world will ever prevent this lmao.

Assuming someones intentions or train of thought is no evidence tho and it shouldn't be treated as that. idk about your example, I didn't read everything in this thread, so I'd rather not comment on that. I agree the commendation system is useless tho and I am 100% indifferent about SE changing, removing or keeping it. I simply couldn't care less since it has 0 value.