Secret Egg Combos~! (Hatching-Tide Event)

[Jacien]

I think for the midnight cap anyway, is the dark egg and then 1 of each color. I was going for an odd egg and got the cap instead.

You have to have the egg cap already in order to get the odd egg. Basically the NPC will go "Oh you already have that item? Take this"

Best thing to do is to use any Fancy Egg, then 2x Color 1, 1x Color 2, 1x Color 3, and 1x Color 4. Choose whatever colors you want, and that'll give you a special dialog moment with the NPC.