Thanks for all the input so far! I admit, I'm rather surprised so many of you vouched for the controllers but it is nice to know that they do actually hold up compared to the KBM controls. I'll still at least give it a try and see how things go, and if it turns out I still favor the controller then at least getting that mouse isn't a total bust either (got that on sale too and I've been wanting to replace the crappy mouse I'm currently using anyway. The extra utility could still be useful for something else). It's also good to know I can apparently sync some of my configurations over from the PS4.