Quote Originally Posted by Alerith View Post
I agree with everything except....

What ability let's you not take physical damage for 45 seconds?
Divine Veil gives you 20... and I was just estimating with Aegis Boon, protect and the mages being up on their stoneskin game

Quote Originally Posted by GreyJorildyn View Post
Yes but clearly since you can having 5-6 DPS pulling 100+ DPS on Coincounter with a WAR tank, killing it in under 2minutes, you don't need all that superfluous enmity PLD can generate. It's a talent that is wasted/lost on that fight.

Extra enmity does not always make up for the loss of significant damage. If you are holding "just enough" enmity to keep stuff of BLMs in the above scenario or are a PLD skyrocketing past their enmity levels, then the largest different in the fight is the lost DPS from the tank.
a valid point....
One thing I don't argue is that WAR is the preferred tank in that fight