Quote Originally Posted by Treach View Post
You don't judge a job based on the players, you judge them against each other and don't count skill factor into it.

For instant threat at the start of a fight warrior wins, for sustained threat warrior wins with dps and collusion and the same skills a PLD would use not counting cures that you can't get enmity with from over curing anymore, if you want to risk dying just so you can get full cure enmity be my guest cause it won't bother me if you die at all.

Disclaimer, this is not warrior fanboy opinions. I personally do not care which tank is currently best, I'll play whichever one it is.
Agreed. I play both and not only do I have an easier time tanking Ifrit on Warrior, our kills are much faster than with a Paladin tank. Hopefully the changes make Paladin worth playing as tank again. Hell even the White Mages prefer the Warrior tank since they have a much larger HP pool. There's more room to wait for a heal with Warrior than with Paladin.