Quote Originally Posted by Phobos View Post
PLD should be so much better than WAR at tanking that anyone who brings up the suggestion (of WAR tanking being better than PLD tanking) gets laughed at because of how ridiculous it is. I mean seriously... it's the main purpose of the job! Even GLA should beat WAR at tanking! WAR should be able to tank, but PLD should be tank king.
I disagree. I believe that both jobs should be approximately equal as far as tanking abilities - maybe one better than the other for some situations, or vice versa - but not one clearly superior to the other in all situations. Tanking is the main purpose of WAR in this game too. It just happens to also be able to deal good damage.

Do you think there should be one DD job that is clearly the best DD job in all situations? If not, why should that apply to tanks?

We'll all be better off if there is more variety available in filling a particular role within a party.