I think FFXIV PvP has some charm to it, and it has grown on me for sure. But I can certainly understand that it doesn't appeal to a majority of people.

However, I think the current size for Frontline is not a good idea when the majority of the population looks away from PvP in general. It needs to become lower numbers. Not even World of Warcraft which is a way heavier PvP game use these large numbers in a single PvP match.