Should commendations be revised?

[Penthea]

Have players who wish to become a mentor register with the Smith after reaching level 80 on one of the required battle jobs. At the end of an instanced duty, a second notice could appear in any groups with a mentor or mentor applicant present asking players if they feel the mentor/mentor applicant performed as a mentor should.

I already find macros with stuff like "commend me please!" to be very annoying, and if the above is introduced to the game I suspect they would become very popular.

Let people commend whoever they want without the game endorsing anyone in any way. Someone should stand out because you noticed something noteworthy, not because the game pointed something out for you.