Eden Savage Loot

[Noitems]

Yes true it dose but also people are rolling against everyone where as before if FENDING gear dropped then only tanks could roll NEED on it - not someone who doesnt play tank but suddenly fancies gearing a tank

I dunno i'd feel pretty awful in that case if I'm rolling against another tank there is a 50/50 chance I can get a piece of gear that MAY drop in my week of playing.

With more and more jobs getting adding I think this coffer system will be the norm, it's if they adopt the ways to manage it that I think the majority will be happy.

[DrWho2010]

how exactly would the game know if you're in a static or not? that's not something the devs should need to take into consideration when creating a loot system.

RNGesus is rngesus.

Also there is 6 MONTHS in a tier. there is plenty of time. just because you can't gear up as fast as some others doesn't mean the system should change.

[Elladie]

I was reading the thread with interest, but then you got very snippy, OP, so I lost interest in what you were saying and any possible solutions you might have to offer. You might want to take on board the suggestion that using an unpleasant tone to people who don't immediately agree with you isn't going to win you fans. Hyomin is a popular poster who always presents her remarks politely; even if I don't agree with her views - I often don't - I always appreciate hearing them for the well presented insights. But you just started to come across as aggressive when she pointed out problems with your solutions

[Mavrias]

Honestly the system youve suggested just sounds like it'll make it harder for pug parties to form. Currently, the way it works allows me to fill any role in a party i please, tank, healer, or dps, and still lot on gear for whatever alt class i please. For example, a party is mostly filled just waiting on tanks, so despite me having all i need from e1s as a tank, i can join that party to get drops for healer.

Under your suggestion, since those healer slots are already filled for that party and i wouldnt be able to roll need as tank, i'd just have to make my own party. Now there are two unfilled parties in party finder.

[Billythepancake]

So, reading your suggestion, I don't think going back to the older system is the best solution,because the new system is just too good to statics to really throw away like that. However, a better solution,I think, would be to add 1 item at the end of every floor (kind of like how e4s drops 1 random weapon and a weapon coffer) and make that item be for something that's currently on your team.