Some thoughts on Level Sync and Abilities

[Noitems]

Honestly to me the only content I feel really lacks any fun for a sync is anything sub 60.

From 60 most jobs have a pretty big kit and can let you get your bearings down for getting the core of your rotation. Like a BLM at sub 60 not having Fire IV just feels so wrong since that's your main mp user.

GNB is one where at 60 I think the kit offers a good amount and the rest to 80 are buffs or help build on it.

[Caitlyn]

I would like to keep my skills even in sync dungeons/bossfights. While all stats will be sync'ed, there should be a problem to keep them with their potencys.

Its just weird, that our beloved hero just forgot how to fight properly just by re-entering a old dungeon. "Oh Sastasha! Long time... but... ah... ummmm... how am I doing this flashy light spell I spammed a few mins ago?" *snips fingers* (WHM - Holy)

[Valkyrie_Lenneth]

I would like to keep my skills even in sync dungeons/bossfights. While all stats will be sync'ed, there should be a problem to keep them with their potencys.

Its just weird, that our beloved hero just forgot how to fight properly just by re-entering a old dungeon. "Oh Sastasha! Long time... but... ah... ummmm... how am I doing this flashy light spell I spammed a few mins ago?" *snips fingers* (WHM - Holy)

You aren't re-entering the dungeon, you are experiencing the past through the echo. Otherwise the same bosses would never be there

[Caitlyn]

You aren't re-entering the dungeon, you are experiencing the past through the echo. Otherwise the same bosses would never be there

When I m experiencing my past, why I can do it with other classes? And other people in my group? And be able to do it Unsync?

[Valkyrie_Lenneth]

When I m experiencing my past, why I can do it with other classes? And other people in my group? And be able to do it Unsync?

Because game mechanics still need to happen. However, your point that your char suddenly forgot how to use their skills can still be explained if they still haven't learned them yet because echo

[MariaArvana]

When I m experiencing my past, why I can do it with other classes? And other people in my group? And be able to do it Unsync?

Because locking you to a single class/job in a dungeon forever would be a very bad idea in a game that promotes multiclassing. Same reasoning applies to the MSQ, why you can somehow be a PLD in one quest and then be a SMN in another, it's a suspension of lore for basic game functions. Unsyncing is just a convenience feature, but canonically you went through the dungeon with a group of adventurers at the proper level of experience you were at during that time.

But lore wise, you are only reliving your experience of the dungeon through the echo, hence you can't use abilities you hadn't learned yet at that level of adventuring.

[Caitlyn]

Because game mechanics still need to happen. However, your point that your char suddenly forgot how to use their skills can still be explained if they still haven't learned them yet because echo

Then how explain how my character forgot how to reload his gun with Shadowbringers. Or why cards doing now different things ; )
Its video game logic, it dont need to be explained xD

[PyurBlue]

Syncing down to any level while retaining all skills would require a monumental amount of work to maintain parity with players actually at those levels. The synced player would have to put in significantly more work just to match a mediocre new player. And if the synced player happens to be sub-optimal themselves, then they become little more than dead weight for the rest of the group.

Out of curiosity, have you ever tried to gear sync yourself? By which I mean going into low level content with outdated gear while out leveling it. It's pretty easy to balance an over leveled character to a dungeon in terms of DPS, provided gear can go low enough. We just need multiplier applied to DPS. The idea that it's something so complicated is at odds with the balance of the entire game through the leveling process which accounts for wild variation in effectiveness of different players already. The perfect THM will outDPS the perfect LNC in an AoE situation by 2, maybe 3 times as it is now. There is no precise balancing required, that's only for end game. The rough numbers for potency sync are already available to SE anyway since boss HP needs to scale with player progression.

[Deceptus]

Aggro is irrelevant in this example. I literally did not mention it once. No part of the "balancing" argument even considers aggro. Because that is the very last thing to worry about, when you stop to look at how it's not remotely as simple as you think it is to just "normalize" damage.

More importantly, the whole point was an example. Pick any job you like. PLD needs balancing just the same, adjusting each step of the way to keep the synced 80 PLD on par with the actual 20 PLD (or gladiator at that point). The level 80 WHM needs balanced so that it's on par, heals and all, with the level 20 CNJ. (frankly, perhaps BLM was the worst example to pick with their lack of utility. BLM would probably be the simplest to balance in this way; any other job and you've got to start factoring in party buffs that those jobs are expected to maintain as well, further complicating the balancing act)

Syncing down to any level while retaining all skills would require a monumental amount of work to maintain parity with players actually at those levels. The synced player would have to put in significantly more work just to match a mediocre new player. And if the synced player happens to be sub-optimal themselves, then they become little more than dead weight for the rest of the group.

And, again, since I'm not really sure where you got the idea in the first place, aggro isn't remotely part of this argument I'm making.

Because aggro is the first thing that most level sync ability naysayers always go to.

How will the level appropriate tank keep aggro on a lvl 80 BLM with all of their skills!

[Valkyrie_Lenneth]

Because aggro is the first thing that most level sync ability naysayers always go to.

How will the level appropriate tank keep aggro on a lvl 80 BLM with all of their skills!

To be fair, that was before the tank changes in 5.0. I haven't seen anyone saying that since.