Tank Options

[Nedkel]

Are you talking about from a healer perspective, a tank perspective, a DPS perspective, a group perspective, a solo perspective, or any combination of the five? Because you need to more specific than that, because healers are supposed to be healing, it's what they are supposed to do, and I do not trust a healer that's going to Holy spam because of the delay on the damage and stun from that.

From tank perspective, Warrior and DRK are better at dungeons.
Warrior has 6 seconds full hp heal (combine it with Thrill of battle and you could kick healer from dungeon xD) and giant amount of aoe dmg, DRK has comparable aoes but has TBN which is super cheesy in dungeons, because if your dont take damage, your healer could spam holy and stun mobs and its only adding up to the speed overall.
DMG alone does not matter if you cant stand your ground, dungeons are all about taking damage and sustaining it.

PLD by far is the best dungeon tank in terms of you getting a random healer. Large pulls you can Hallowed Ground the first big pull and last big pull. And if your healer is bad you can Requescat and clemency for 70- 90k health instantly. DRK is second with TBN being so powerful but cant fully save you if you have a undergeared healer, with WAR falling to 3rd and GNB last for dungeons.

When comparing tanks for dungeons you have to look at both healing side and tank side.

However i have noticed if you are in a group without a WHM dungeons become slightly more challenging without the stun from Holy Spam.

Warrior could heal for about 80-90k on 6 mobs with his AOE and he deals damage as well.