Personally, I don’t think it’s unreasonable to request exp and quest rewards. I do believe some people in this thread are lacking in their abilities when it comes to presenting their arguments in a respectable manner...

FFXIV is story focused, so this will not be unpopular, even without the rewards. Would it be nice to have another method of levelling jobs? Sure. Though that wasn’t NG+’s intended purpose. No harm in kindly asking, though.