Quote Originally Posted by Gula View Post
Why would you get rewards... that you already got?
That argument makes sense when it comes to a lot of the specific item rewards, but for generic things like XP and gil, it's the same reason you get them again if you replay a dungeon you've already run, or do a FATE again which you've run before, craft an item you've made before, and so on. Most repeatable content has repeatable rewards.

In this case, the original rewards were designed and balanced around the idea that they'd be a one time thing, so they shouldn't be just carried over as-is into New Game plus as repeatable rewards. They'd need to be reconfigured for a repeatable reward balance.

(Personally, I'm of the opinion that that's likely to be more effort than it's worth, since those rewards aren't needed here, but opinions can vary on that.)