i'm not that experienced with the scholar but tbh the scholar kit feels like a mess to me and really dont reflect him or his lore that much.

the 2 fairies are identical ,other then just extra ogcd heal that just follow you around i don't see any other use for them.
for a tactical support class who has pets and shields , he feels like its mostly him and the pet is barely an extra and his skilled don't really reflect any tactical versatility.

when i picture a scholar i picture something like an alphinaud vibe that need to come from his kit ,that the scholar and the pets should have coordination and although he is a weak healer and dps he makes up with it by strengthening his team with his strategy and tactic.

but with the kit right now it feels more chaotic rather then tactic:

1.i feel like the pet is extra and is there just to follow you rather to be a diverse tool that the scholar can really use.
for example the fairy can be an extension and allow scholars to have an increase range to apply heals then the other healers,or have the 2 fairies different kits for support.

for a support class that uses summons and pet as his tool,i expected the scholar to have more interactions with his pets,have them attached to party members or maybe have some combinations skills with them rather then just follow their master and execute skill on demand.

2.the scholar kit is mostly casting heals rather to be diverse, heals are important but there should be more then just heals to him like certain buffs that he can use for different situations ,they don't have to be important raid buffs like damage/crit or even be a party buffs but rather be diverse skills for any situation like speed,cc negations the healing potency of the fairy is rather nice different skills that show adaptability and reflect some tactics in his kits.

In summery,my personal opinion is that the scholar kit really feel that it doesn't represent him and need to be rework and the devs need to think about what his play style should be.
there are good skills in his kit and as people mention they love but i feel that right now with the scholar kit the devs haven't figure what direction the scholar should take.
should he be of a pet class and have more pet skills or maybe give him more self cast skills,what the true point for his pets?
i guess the end result will be probably the same as the other 2 and will give him a kit that is identical and as right now make the pets as ogcd skills but for a tactical and advance job i guess i expected him to have more situational skills(not necessarily more dps/dots skills) and a rather complex play then the other supports.