No.
If you don't clear the dps check you can't clear the raid = no loot.
Why should I work on my performance so I'm able to beat savage whilst others can just autoattack the boss and still get loot?
When I first started raiding my group couldn't beat A8S dps check for a month before we were burned out and gave up, so we didn't deserve to clear the fight and get loot.
Now I'm a better player and my static is better. We didn't clear E1S adds on our first try (granted, we only raided for an hour so we had death debuffs from figuring out mechanics) so we're getting better gear, working on rotation, and hopefully tomorrow we make it. Why should be be rewarded for underperforming?