Quote Originally Posted by Absimiliard View Post
His "crowning act of stupidity", as Emet-Selch so eloquently put it, leads me believe the character really doesn't /deserve/ another chance.
In retrospect, that line is incredibly ironic, given Emet had plenty of chances to just completely end us, yet didn't. The opposite in fact, he straight up saved Y'shtola. He wanted us to be consumed by the Light, yet left without doing anything to the Scions, who managed to buy us enough time to come back and ultimately end him. He had us run a dungeon which ultimately brought us to where he was keeping G'raha, allowing him to help us out in the very end too... Heck, if Y'shtolas theory is correct, it's our fight against him which ultimately saved us by spending that Light in battle... All Emet needed to do was never mention Tempest and his plan to have us turn would probably have completely succeeded...

I'd honestly say that's all more of a crowning act of stupidity than anything Lahabrea did... What was his mistake? Not expecting the Pope to double cross him? I'll admit, that's stupid, but Emet practically begged us, a notorious Ascian slayer, to come kill him...