I didn't like Alphinaud at first but he grew on me after his character development. Alisae is just really bland to me, though. It's a shame she gets a free pass from many. I could speculate as to why that may be but I'll keep my lips sealed to avoid drama!

I can already see her being Shadowbringer's version of Lyse. I'm sure she'll charge into a fight many times and miraculously be rescued at the last possible second with absolutely no real change to her behaviour.