Silvertear Skies plot hole

[Nalien]

Especially since his tone towards us when we first met is that of arrogant condescension.

See, that's exactly why I don't think he made some big mistake. Had he failed in his duty like that, I'd expect him to have been a tad more humble and acknowledge the mistake, then continue to chastise us regarding the Dragonsong War. He never struck me as the type to talk down to others because of his failings.

no I personally don't think that flies since my impression of him is that of loyalty to Hydaelyn.

Really? I kind of got the impression that he didn't really care. He formed a covenant with Her, and he'll uphold it, but is that loyalty? My impression was more that he was just keeping up his end of the deal. He does his part and peaces out for a nap, constantly.

Also, it's worth noting how we obtained our Blessing of Light; For the most part, we gained our Crystals by fighting Primals, seems to me like they might have been part of the plan to forge a Warrior of Light, no?