The Healer Double Standard

[vetch]

And we jaded veterans were told to "wait and see". The same thing we've been told for the past 2 expansions since the great purge of Stormblood.

Sorry, but what even would there be to 'wait and see' about?

Healer oGCDs are so powerful and so plentiful and so bland that if there were ever a piece of content designed to actually make them burn through them all to the point that they need to dip into GCD healing, it would have to be blasting the entire party to critical health every five seconds -- because healers certainly don't have any role-wide oGCDs about curing statuses or applying some kind of utility that we can pander to, it's all chunk healing and mitigation -- and if it's damage by rote like the rest of FF14 damage, it'll be extremely stressful for the healers who can't map out their healing while being about as boring as current content for the ones who can. And if that level of damage goes out pseudo-randomly, that's even more terrifying!

So I'm confused and alarmed as to what the content we're supposed to be waiting for with this healer design would look like.

[Liam_Harper]

Remember when we were dissuaded from our worries 6.0 was making healers even more braindead, by the promise high-end content would be specifically designed with our stupidly bloated kits in mind? lol

I enjoyed the predictions for Endwalker.

"Yoshida said they would be giving healers more to heal! Pure healing is going to be a playstyle, the way of the filthy dps healer is over! You won't have time to dps next expansion, we're going to need our GCD heals!"

It was entertaining. And of course it turned out exactly the way we said it would.

[RyuDragnier]

Again, if they want to give us more to heal, they're going to have to completely rework all the healers to where GCDs are our only healing sources and oGCDs can only provide mitigation or buffs. But we know they won't do this, they don't have the guts to bring us back to HW levels of healing, because people would just cry that it's too hard, like they did back then.

[Supersnow845]

Again, if they want to give us more to heal, they're going to have to completely rework all the healers to where GCDs are our only healing sources and oGCDs can only provide mitigation or buffs. But we know they won't do this, they don't have the guts to bring us back to HW levels of healing, because people would just cry that it's too hard, like they did back then.

They really don’t even have to do even close to that

If they left the healing exactly how it is but then every time the boss hit the tank it did a small 5-10% raidwide we would need to be GCD healing a lot more (sort of like how you can’t leave people low health during FOA because of the fire rain ticks), I’m not saying this particular example would be terribly fun but it’s an easy example of how they can keep our bloated kits, keep damage predictable and still force us to heal a whole lot more than we currently do

[CrazyAce]

Lul, I can still basically play WHM with nothing but Regen and Medica II for anything that's not Extreme or Savage (and even then I forget to use a lot of abilities because I simply don't need to). Or an Alliance raid where everyone stands in mechanics.

Healing is such a joke. It's the class I play when I want to turn off my brain and just concentrate on mechanics, because only needing to use less than 6 buttons aside from movement is pretty laughable.

The fact that current Savage tiers have been completed without healers is proof enough that the role is practically superfluous these days. We're more a safety blanket for the greed-god DPS players that mistime the AOE snapshots.

[ToodlesElNoodles]

I think that’s a bit much..

Can Savage be cleared Week 1 without healers? Has P3S been cleared without healers?

It points less to the healers and more about how power scaling of players from gearing might need to be reined in a bit.

[vetch]

I think that’s a bit much..

Can Savage be cleared Week 1 without healers? Has P3S been cleared without healers?

It points less to the healers and more about how power scaling of players from gearing might need to be reined in a bit.

Falling back to an ever-shrinking perimeter of where healers are allowed to be necessary is not a defense, it's a step away from giving up.

[RyuDragnier]

Remember back when auto attacks were the tankbusters? Remember when W2W pulling required the entire team to be good or it would fail with a party wipe? Remember when healers had to use everything including their GCD heals to avoid the party wiping? Emet-Selch remembers.

[Nizzi]

Can Savage be cleared Week 1 without healers? Has P3S been cleared without healers?

I think the fact that you're having to even ask the question instead of being confident in knowing that it cannot happen at all is reason enough to know there's a glaring fundamental problem with this rotting, dead role.

[Supersnow845]

Falling back to an ever-shrinking perimeter of where healers are allowed to be necessary is not a defense, it's a step away from giving up.

It’s literally just another way of saying “lol go play ultimate”,

Got a game people endlessly laude as being amazingly casual friendly and fun for everyone they sure do like to make healers completely irrelevant for all but the absolute most difficult content, but then again they are aiming for the “I spam cure 1 and love it (while the WAR heals himself and grounds his teeth into nubs over cure 1’s horrible sound effect)” audience so maybe irrelevant healer that feels like they are contributing without any actual chance of messing anything up is what they are going for