I'm also sort of a click - hotkey hybrid. Usually the far right side of my hotbars I'll click, things like limit break, utility, some aoe. The bulk is hotkey though.

To give ff14 credit, it taught me to hotkey. In WoW, no joke, I played on a laptop using the touchpad (no mouse at all) and clicked nearly everything and I was generally one of the top dps in my group. It worked fine, I could get away with it. In ff14 that just doesn't work and I naturally found myself having to learn to hotkey, strafe and learn to move efficiently while dps'ing. You can say ff14 is a casual game, but for me WoW combat was miles easier.